Protectionist Policies Hurt the Poor

by | Nov 20, 2016

Protectionist Policies Hurt the Poor

by | Nov 20, 2016

The Trump Policy that Will ‘Shrink the Economy and Make the US Poorer’

President-elect Donald Trump’s anti-trade rhetoric has proven that bad economics can make good politics. Fortunately, after Mr. Trump assumes office his trade policies likely will be better than his campaign rhetoric.

Many factors contributed to Trump’s victory. His upset wins in the so-called ‘Rust Belt’ states, which are typically Democratic strongholds, can be linked to his promise to revive U.S. manufacturing by restricting “unfair” trade with Mexico, China and other countries.

This promise resonated well with union workers. Trump won the union vote in Ohio, tied Clinton among union households in Michigan, and narrowly lost the union vote in Wisconsin by 8 percentage points – a huge improvement over 2012 Republican candidate Mitt Romney.

The reason Mr. Trump’s rhetoric on trade resonated with so many blue collar voters is because they believe a popular fallacy: that foreign trade destroys U.S. jobs.

According to exit polls, 50 percent of voters in Wisconsin and Michigan agreed with the notion that international trade kills American jobs. Similarly, 53 percent of Pennsylvanian voters and 48 percent of Ohio voters bought into this fallacy. Among the voters in the four states who expressed agreement with the trade fallacy, Trump’s support ranged from 59 percent in Michigan to 67 percent in Ohio.

Yet, as any trade economist understands, the truth is that trade neither creates nor destroys jobs.

Read the rest at the Independent Institute.

Benjamin Powell

Benjamin Powell is Senior Fellow at the Independent Institute, Director of the Free Market Institute at Texas Tech University, and former President of the Association of Private Enterprise Education. Dr. Powell received his Ph.D. in economics from George Mason University and his Bachelor of Science degree in Finance and Economics from the University of Massachusetts at Lowell. He has been Associate Professor of Economics at Suffolk University, Assistant Professor of Economics at San Jose State University, a Fellow with the Mercatus Center's Global Prosperity Initiative, and a Visiting Research Fellow with the American Institute for Economic Research.

View all posts

Our Books

Recent Articles

Recent

TGIF: Notes on Anarcho-Capitalism

TGIF: Notes on Anarcho-Capitalism

I'm pretty sure I won't be around long enough to see anarcho-capitalism—or what I call market-ordered anarchism—prevail in the United States. I'm just as sure that I won't see government strictly limited to protecting individual rights and never violating them (if...

read more
WMDs for a MIC in Need

WMDs for a MIC in Need

In the closing days of 2025, the White House turned an opioid crisis into a national security drama. Standing in the Oval Office during a Mexican Border Defense Medal ceremony on December 15, President Donald Trump declared that he would sign an executive order to...

read more
Smashing the ‘Roosevelt Myth’

Smashing the ‘Roosevelt Myth’

David T. Beito’s FDR: A New Political Life offers a bracing, deeply researched, and welcome reassessment of Franklin Delano Roosevelt, one that decisively breaks with the hagiographic tradition that has dominated twentieth century American historiography. The book’s...

read more

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This