Were the Branch Davidians a ‘Suicide Cult?’

by | Aug 16, 2019

Were the Branch Davidians a ‘Suicide Cult?’

by | Aug 16, 2019

Even people who can’t tell you what agencies were involved in the Waco massacre will say, “They were a suicide cult and set themselves on fire!” We’ll look at the fire, and who started it, at a later date. For now, let’s see if there is any evidence that the Branch Davidians were planning to kill themselves. 

Davidian Doctrine 

The Branch Davidian’s main focus of study is on the return of Christ. This is evident in the fact that Koresh was famous throughout the world for his exposition of the Seven Seals of the Book of Revelation. Waco survivor David Thibodeau remembers his first “feast celebration” in Waco, “People started flying in from all over, for this very reason to learn the Seals. And like, one night a group of people would come in from England and another night it would be a group of people coming in from New Zealand, Australia, it was pretty interesting, I kept meeting all these people from different areas of the world, it was fascinating to be honest with you.” (12:52) 

The Seven Seals are believed to be a description of what’s to happen before and during Christ’s Second Coming. There are many interpretations of the Seven Seals, and the “Second Coming.” Some include believers being spared from judgment by a physical “rapture,” a “catching up” into the air to meet Jesus. Some have believers suffering through the judgment. None that I can find, including those of Davidian teachings, have believers killing themselves. When asked by this author if the BDs under Koresh were a “suicide cult,” David Thibodeau responded, “Was there a planned suicide? No. We had talked about coming out, I think there was a time when David was really paranoid during the 51-day siege. There was a lot going on there, there were a lot of lies watching the press conferences every day. The FBI would tell us one thing and do something totally different in the press conferences. So, we got that, we’re being screwed with by the Feds. They’re telling us that they’re not going to come onto the property with tanks, then they’re saying in the press conferences they had to bring tanks in because we were doing things to provoke them, which was not true…but no, there wasn’t a plan to kill ourselves.” (38:45) 

Fellow survivor, Livingstone Fagan, stated, “There was never any suicide pact or plan, there was, however, an expressed reaffirmation amongst certain individuals in the course of events, of their willingness to die for what they believed, rather than surrender to the authority of their persecutors.” (p. 218),  

Another Davidian, Sheila Martin, wife of Harvard educated attorney Wayne Martin (who made the 911 call and eventually died in the fire), added that if a suicide pact was discussed, she didn’t know of it, nor would she have agreed. “I never heard that David had such a plan, or approved of such a plan.” (Ibid., p. 218) 

Was Koresh a Cult Leader and Psychopath? 

Anyone who reads the FBI transcripts of the negotiations with Koresh will quickly see that David hated the term Cult and refused to elevate himself above a Bible teacher.  

This exchange between Koresh and ATF supervisor Jim Cavanaugh shows this explicitly: 

Koresh: All right. Does [God] have a book with Seven Seals? 

Cavanaugh: Yes, he does. 

Koresh: Is Psalm 45 the first seal? 

Cavanaugh: Well, I’m not sure. But, if you say so, I’ll take your word. 

Koresh: You can’t do that. That makes you like a cult follower…I’m not a cult leader. I’m a Bible teacher, okay? (FBI Negotiation transcripts, 3/1/93, pp. 21-22) 

Did David Koresh have ideas that were way out of the norm? Yes. Did his students agree to go along with practices you or I wouldn’t? Probably. Did things happen that were outside of the State’s legal parameters at the time? Apparently. We do know that former students left because they weren’t willing to go along with some of David’s practices.  

The question that must be asked is, “did the amount of violence that was threatened by the State equal the threat to the public?” No. If the government were truly concerned for the welfare of the children inside Mount Carmel, why did they show up with what was essentially an “army?” 

As to David Koresh’s mental state, Harvard professor of Law and Psychiatry, Alan A. Stone, states, “I think that Koresh was not a criminal psychopath. He had, as a youngster, spent months memorizing the Bible. And particularly these passages about the seven seals and that sort of repetitive study, memorization, throwing yourself into that kind of disciplined project is not what sociopaths do. And he was able to convince the other people by his knowledge of the Bible and the way he put it together–that’s how he convinced people like Mr. Martin and Mr. Schneider, who were both intelligent, serious people. Mr. Martin was a graduate of Harvard Law School. He was one of our earliest African American graduates. He was certainly not a weirdo, he was certainly not a criminal, he was certainly not a psychopath. He had gone on and done religious studies after leaving Harvard Law School and had become interested in Koresh’s teachings. That is how he got into the compound. So, the idea that these people like Schneider and Martin were somehow criminal types or people who had just sort of been buffaloed by Koresh I think is a most unfortunate mis-characterization.” (19:20) 

Sociopaths normally show a strong disdain for law enforcement. The fact that Koresh and the Davidians were friendly, and even entertained Sheriff Harwell on multiple occasions, would cast doubt upon that. Again, a conversation between David and Jim Cavanaugh sheds light on Koresh’s worldview: 

Koresh: I wish, I wish you knew the Seven Seals. 

Cavanaugh: David, listen, ah, ah, you’ve explained them to me.  

Koresh: No, no, I haven’t. I’ve not even scratched the surface. Just like, uh, just like I told, uh…Jerry–Jerry Gonzales? 

Cavanaugh: Yeah. 

Koresh: Robert Gonzales. [Cover name of ATF undercover agent Robert Rodriguez] I really liked that guy too. I’ve always loved law enforcement, because y’all guys risk your lives every day, you know. 

Cavanaugh: I understand. Let me… 

Koresh: (Sadly) I’m so sorry that… 

Cavanaugh: Aw, David, we know that(pp. 166-7) 

This doesn’t sound like the maniac the government and press made him out to be. Koresh does not boast of his people’s prowess in the gunfight with the ATF, he instead complains to Cavanaugh, “Now there’s a bunch of men dead, and there’s a bunch of you guys dead. Now, that’s your fault!” (Ibid., p. 166) Koresh appears to know there is a party at fault here and that is not the normal reaction of a suicidal, sociopath. 

About Peter R. Quiñones

Peter R. Quiñones hosts the Free Man Beyond the Wall podcast. He released his first book, Freedom Through Memedom – The 31-day Guide to Waking Up to Liberty in November 2017. It reached #4 in the Libertarian Section on Amazon. He has spoken at Liberty Forum in Manchester, New Hampshire and is one of the Executive Producers on the documentary, “The Monopoly on Violence."

Our Books

thisone

Related Articles

Related

How Much Worse Can the Economy Get?

How Much Worse Can the Economy Get?

The most important question for asset prices right now, from stocks to houses to Bitcoin, is whether we’re due for a recession. Last week we got confirmation that according to the traditional definition of a recession—two quarters of negative growth—we are already in...

read more
Veteran Says Good Riddance to Liz Cheney

Veteran Says Good Riddance to Liz Cheney

Yesterday was a very important day. It’s the day the America First movement exiled the most despicable, most debased Swamp Monster on Capitol Hill. Yesterday Liz Cheney lost renomination for Congress after three terms of using and abusing the people of Wyoming. The...

read more
In Rebuke of the Dishonorable David Petraeus

In Rebuke of the Dishonorable David Petraeus

In a recent article for The Atlantic David Petraeus came to the conclusion that American soldiers should still be in Afghanistan today. Two thousand, three hundred twenty-four American servicemen killed, $2.3 trillion dollars and over 20 years later convicted criminal...

read more
We Don’t Believe You

We Don’t Believe You

David French, maybe National Review’s most reliably wrong scribe, issued this gem in response to the FBI raid on Donald Trump’s residence in Florida: Imagine thinking federal police agents and lawyers will be “held accountable,” or that presidents are not above the...

read more
How to End the Culture War

How to End the Culture War

The following is a section from The Voluntaryist Handbook, organized by Keith Knight. There exist two blatant contradictions which roughly ninety-nine percent of intellectuals, journalists, and voters erroneously believe. On the one hand, they say that the free market...

read more
Cops Sicced on 8 Year Old Girl’s Lemonade Stand

Cops Sicced on 8 Year Old Girl’s Lemonade Stand

Asa Baker is an 8-year-old girl from Ohio with an overwhelming entrepreneurial spirit. Over the hot summer, rather than spend the days inside watching TV, Asa would set up a lemonade stand in her front yard to make some cash. “It’s fun and you get lots of people,”...

read more

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This