What The Public Goods Category Really Is

by | Aug 14, 2017

The economic concept of public goods is the singular justification for government’s existence in the American “republican” political tradition.  But what is this category actually?  Many libertarian thinkers have deconstructed many ostensible public goods and demonstrated why they don’t necessarily belonging to this category.  Roads, utilities, the environment, even law can all be managed privately through voluntary interaction in the civil society – at least in theory.  These goods don’t necessarily belong to the public goods category.

I was thinking about the sheep on the commons, and the enclosures which ended the “tragedy of the commons”.  Was the commons really a public good?  Or was it a by-product of a society previously held in a artificial serfdom?  Perhaps something appears as a public good because of historical relationships between former rent-seeking behavior by political tyrants, and the enduring cultural norms that develop around this behavior.  The legacy of this rent-seeking in places where it’s cheaper (public, or high-traffic areas like roads, towns, and marketplaces) might cause cultural habits that treat this high-traffic category as a commons.

Maybe the public goods category isn’t an economic category, but a socio-cultural and political category.  Maybe the state founded to regulate this category is nothing but a concession to our cultural habits which because of history seek and expect some kind of rulership.

About Zack Sorenson

Zachary Sorenson was a captain in the United States Air Force before quitting because of a principled opposition to war. He received a MBA from Waseda University in Tokyo, Japan as class valedictorian. He also has a BA in Economics and a BS in Computer Science.

Our Books

latest book lineup.

Related Articles

Related

Ban “Ethnic Cleansing”

I propose that we defenders of individual rights stop using the term ethnic cleansing. Why? Because it is the sort of euphemism bad people would use to disguise what they are doing when they expel or annihilate large numbers of people viewed as members of the wrong...

read more

The Eternal Panopticon: The State as Predator

Lizard Farmer did an excellent synopsis of how the state stalks its prey. The observations are older but still germane. If London had this technology in 1770, America would not have been born and Paul Revere, the Committees of Correspondence and his colleagues would...

read more