How to Tell if a Politician is Evil or Ignorant (feat. Bryan Caplan, Ph.D.)

by | Sep 20, 2022

My case for pacifism, to recap, comes down to three simple premises. The first two are empirical:

Premise #1: The short-run costs of war are clearly awful. [Empirical claim about immediate effects of war].
Premise #2: The long-run benefits of war are highly uncertain. [Empirical claim about people’s ability to accurately forecast the long-run effects of war].

These empirical claims imply pacifism when combined with a bland moral premise:

Premise #3: For a war to be morally justified, the expected long-run benefits have to substantially exceed its short-run costs. [Moral claim, inspired by Judith Jarvis Thomson’s forced organ donation hypothetical].

Bryan Caplan, “How Evil Are Politicians?: Essays on Demagoguery.” p. 125

Dr. Bryan Caplan is a Professor of Economics at George Mason University and New York Times bestselling author.

Buy Caplan’s new book, How Evil Are Politicians? on Amazon.

Follow Caplan on Substack here.

BitChute

Flote

Archive

Spotify

Keith Knight

Keith Knight

Keith Knight is Managing Editor at the Libertarian Institute, host of the Don't Tread on Anyone podcast and editor of The Voluntaryist Handbook: A Collection of Essays, Excerpts, and Quotes.

View all posts

Our Books

Shop books published by the Libertarian Institute.

libetarian institute longsleeve shirt

Support via Amazon Smile

Our Books

15 books

Recent Articles

Recent

The Politically Incorrect Guide to Pearl Harbor

The Politically Incorrect Guide to Pearl Harbor

https://youtu.be/TkJc66nL19c At the time, Henry Lewis Stimson was the U.S. Secretary of War, and in the 1946 “Investigation of the Pearl Harbor Attack” Stimson’s diary is brought into evidence. On page 177, the report cites a diary entry from November 25, 1941, almost...

read more
WTF Happened in 1971?

WTF Happened in 1971?

https://youtu.be/vdFBoGZycRI The second week of August the British Ambassador appeared at the treasury Department to ask that three billion dollars be converted into gold. Whether we honored or denied this request the consequences of our action would be fraught with...

read more
The Pro-War Roots of Progressivism

The Pro-War Roots of Progressivism

https://youtu.be/KB4JaO7v-FI What makes government a unique institution in society is its widely recognized right to achieve its ends via threats of violence against nonaggressors. This is why you would go to jail for trying to “tax” someone’s income, or if you...

read more

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This