Liberty at the Movies: Vice

by | Mar 2, 2019

Liberty at the Movies: Vice

by | Mar 2, 2019

Vice tells the story of how Richard Chaney went from being expelled from Yale and drinking and fighting in his spare time to becoming the most influential Vice-President in history.

Written and directed by Adam McKay who also directed The Big Short, Vice employs the same techniques that made The Big Short one of, if not the, best movies to address the 2008 financial crisis. Like the Big Short, Vice uses a short entertaining vignette to explain complex concepts. The film also has an excellent cast, starting with Christian Bale as Dick Cheney and Amy Adams as Liz Cheney (who the film portrays as the motivating force behind Dicks decision to clean himself up and enter government). Fans of The Office will enjoy Steve Carrell’s portrayal of Donald Rumsfeld as a smarter, shrewder, more ruthless and self-aware Michael Scott.

Libertarians will enjoy the films critique of the Iraqi war and the rise of the surveillance state. They will also enjoy the films exposition on the unified executive theory— which is the idea that the President has unchecked authority to run the executive branch without interference from Congress or the courts.

The unified executive theory is presented as the basis of Cheney’s worldview from the moment he is informed of it by a young lawyer named Antonin Scalia. However, the film portrays Cheney as embracing the unified executive theory simply as a means to enhancer his power. There is no suggestion that Cheney held an ideological commitment to America serving as the world’s policemen abroad while promoting a conservative pro-business welfare -regulatory state at home. For Cheney it is all about the money and the power.

Vice presents a left-liberal cartoon version of the entire conservative movement which is shown as nothing more than an attempt by billionaires to subvert democracy for their own benefit. There is no attempt to explore conservatives libertarian ideas, and all “right -wing” policies are presented as equally bad. The makers of the film are the type of progressives to whom cutting taxes is an equal or greater sin than starting a war.

The film gets key facts wrong as well. For example, there are claims the Koch brothers were part of the right wing billionaire plot to take over the country by ousting Jimmy Carter and replacing him with Ronald Reagan. At the time the Kochs were financing the Libertarian Party. The film also lumps in the CATO Institute with conservative think tanks, ignoring CATO’s opposition to the Iraqi war and the Patriot Act. Of course, there is no mention of the fact that the most consistent critique of Bush-Cheney politics came from a certain pro-life, pro-gun and pro-gold Texas Congressman.

Vice also presents George Bush as a clownish buffoon who lets Cheney act as virtual President. While it is true Cheney had more influence than any other Vice President, he was not actually running the country. Another scene that does not ring true is when Cheney and his advisors discuss the people and dismiss them as “lightweights”. You can say a lot about Karl Rove (and I don’t have much good to say about him) but he is not a lightweight.

In conclusion, Vice is worth seeing for the acting and entertaining way it tells the story but it present a false history of the Bush-Cheney years and the American right.

Republished from campaignforliberty.org.

Norman Singleton

Norman Singleton

Norman Singleton is currently a Senior Fellow at the Market Institute. Mr. Singleton worked for Congressman Ron Paul from 1997-2012. Mr. Singleton served as Legislative Aide on Education and Workforce issues for Congressman Paul from 1997-2001, when he became Congressman Paul’s Legislative Director, a position he held until Congressman Paul left Congress in 2013. Mr. Singleton also served as volunteer policy director for the Ron Paul 2012 Presidential Campaign. Prior to working for Ron Paul, Mr. Singleton worked for the National Right to Work Committee. Mr. Singleton graduated Cum Laude from Washington and Jefferson College with a degree in economics and is a 1991 graduate of the University Of Pittsburgh School Of Law. He is also a founding member of the Republican Liberty Caucus.

View all posts

Our Books

libertarian inst books

Related Articles

Related

TGIF: What Free Market in Health Care?

TGIF: What Free Market in Health Care?

Contrary to a popular article of faith, America has no free market in health care—far from it. Consider this: the largest lobby in Washington, D.C., is—wait for it—the health care and health insurance industries. Last year, they spent 5.8 times the amount the...

read more
A Critique of Practical Hasbara

A Critique of Practical Hasbara

Immanuel Kant published The Critique of Pure Reason in 1781. It was the same year the Rebel Alliance triumphed at Yorktown, Virginia. The victory at Yorktown made possible the decline of the British “liberal” empire and the eventual rise of Washinton DCs “non-empire”...

read more
The Switzerland Summit: Peace Through Delusion

The Switzerland Summit: Peace Through Delusion

Ukraine has been at war for over ten years, and even the political establishment wipeout in the European elections has not managed to shock the Western ruling class back into coherence. Nothing could provide a clearer example of their clownish nature than the recent...

read more
Smashing the UK’s Statist Mindset

Smashing the UK’s Statist Mindset

Mainstream British political thought processes contain an epidemic of dreadful reasoning. Witness the average political interaction between “popular” British parliamentarians and voters, think through the reasoning of the topics discussed, and you will know exactly...

read more
Will Trump Learn from Bump Stock Battering?

Will Trump Learn from Bump Stock Battering?

The Supreme Court last Friday struck down one of the most controversial gun control edicts in recent years. The ruling on bump stocks is being widely hailed as a victory for an expansive reading of the Second Amendment. But it is also a stark rebuke to Donald Trump’s...

read more

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This