Neocon Control is Slipping Away

by | Apr 23, 2024

Neocon Control is Slipping Away

by | Apr 23, 2024


Quite a bizarre sight in the U.S. House the other day: Hundreds of Democrats waved the Ukrainian flag and chanted the name of a foreign nation as they voted to send still another enormous “aid package” to anyone on earth other than Americans.

Now I expect this kind of behavior from Democrats, because they are enemies of civilization and because they think nothing of looting productive Americans.

The smarter and more decent Republicans know better, though the America Last Romney wing is still dominant in Congress.

But as the Democrats continue to morph into the war and intervention and CIA party, and a wing of the Republican Party (and a sizable chunk of the intellectual branch of conservatism) by contrast grows weary of the dumb bipartisan foreign policy and no longer has much interest in parroting the CNN/CIA narrative 24 hours a day, it’s been interesting to watch the gatekeepers of conservative opinion grow concerned.

For example, on Joe Rogan the other day, Tucker Carlson made neocons’ heads explode when he said that the atomic bombings of Japan had been moral abominations. Now I know I will receive some replies assuring me that the bombings were wonderful, the best thing that ever happened to Japan, the only way to bring about a Japanese surrender, etc. You can rest assured that I am familiar with the arguments.

As were G.E.M. Anscombe and Pat Buchanan, for that matter, who both condemned the bombings as moral enormities, and who were both ever so slightly more conservative than the world’s Sean Hannitys and Bill O’Reillys, who can always be counted on to make excuses for the regime.

The gatekeepers won’t allow us to think like Tucker. We are evidently confined to analysis that runs along the lines of “USA! USA!”

Here’s the response of The Spectator‘s Ben Domenech:

The truth is this: Tucker is in every way the superior of Ben Domenech. Despite my disagreements with him, I consider Tucker to be one of the best communicators I have ever come across. I could not improve on a single one of his monologues.

Then Jeremy Boreing of the Daily Wire said this:

These are not the words of a confident man. These are the words of a man who senses the movement he has spent years policing beginning to slip out of his grasp.

And notice the neoconservative mind at work. Neither Tucker nor anyone else says “America” is evil for dropping the bombs, or whatever other complaint you and I might have about what the American government does. The regime is not “America,” though neocons and leftists have their own reasons for wanting to conflate the two.

If I accuse the U.S. regime of lying or of engaging in wicked behavior, that has nothing to do with “hating this country,” since, thank goodness, the U.S. presidents are not “this country.”

At the time of the Spanish-American War, U.S. Senator Carl Schurz had had enough of the “be loyal to the country” nonsense. He, too, could see the games the warmongers were playing:

Again in our own time, we hear with the old persistency the same old plea to the voters of the nation to be loyal to the country, right or wrong. And when we probe the matter—nor is much probing necessary—we find that we are being urged to be loyal not to the country right or wrong, but to President McKinley right or wrong.

President McKinley wasn’t the country in 1898 any more than Harry Truman was in 1945 or Joe Biden is today.

This is where the Ben Domenechs and Jeremy Boreings join hands in happy concord with the Democrats. Sure, you’re allowed to have this or that criticism of the government, but when it comes to the truly defining issues, issues on which the regime relies for its moral legitimacy, you are expected to be in lockstep—as Ben and Jeremy are—with the very Romney/Clinton/Bush/Biden Axis of Evil they pretend to oppose.

Now with that off my chest, I can head to dinner at Per Se, here in New York City, where I’m visiting this week.

This article was originally featured as a Tom Woods newsletter and is republished with permission.

About Thomas E. Woods, Jr.

Thomas E. Woods, Jr., is a senior fellow of the Libertarian Institute, the Mises Institute and host of The Tom Woods Show, which releases a new episode every weekday. He holds a bachelor’s degree in history from Harvard and his master’s, M.Phil., and Ph.D. from Columbia University. Woods has appeared on CNBC, MSNBC, FOX News Channel, FOX Business Network, C-SPAN, and Bloomberg Television, among other outlets, and has been a guest on hundreds of radio programs. Woods is the author of twelve books, most recently Real Dissent: A Libertarian Sets Fire to the Index Card of Allowable Opinion, Rollback: Repealing Big Government Before the Coming Fiscal Collapse and Nullification: How to Resist Federal Tyranny in the 21st Century.

Our Books

latest book lineup.

Related Articles


The Continuing Farce of the U.S. Tariff War

The Continuing Farce of the U.S. Tariff War

In recent years, American politics has been mired in a narrative of fear and suspicion surrounding China—a narrative perpetuated by successive administrations, defined by nothing so much as speculation and hysteria, and which has fueled the production of a plethora of...

read more
Inheriting Wealth is Good for You (And Society)

Inheriting Wealth is Good for You (And Society)

It seems as if hardly a week goes by that we don’t hear about some celebrity or industrialist saying that he doesn’t intend to leave his fortune to his children. There is a widespread belief in the Anglophone world that inheriting money will make children lazy and...

read more