Neoconservatives and hawks of various stripes know why Republicans lost disastrously in the 2026 midterm elections: tariffs.
They have a point. Polls did show that voter disapproval of President Donald Trump’s tariffs and other issues did help Democrats win big.
But those same neocons and hawks will not admit that polls showed the singular issue that cost Republicans more than any other was the Iran war and its effect on rising costs.
Even more than tariffs. Significantly more.
After election day and the inevitable start of 2028 Republican presidential discussions, we heard about Vice President J.D. Vance’s prospects, Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s potential path to the White House, and also possibly that of outgoing Florida Governor Ron DeSantis.
But none of these men opposed the Iran War before the midterms and all of them supported the tariffs.
There is exactly one Republican senator who consistently opposed both the Iran war and the tariffs—and who is also reportedly mulling over a 2028 presidential run.
That’s Senator Rand Paul of Kentucky, who originally ran for president in 2016 and got wiped out like every other Republican candidate that year by what turned out to be the insurmountable phenomenon known as Donald Trump.
So would neocons and hawks now insisting tariffs were the main culprit in the midterms be open to a Rand Paul campaign based around the benefits of free trade?
“It’s simply a fact that in the Republican Party being hawkish and strong on defense gets you more votes than being dovish and weak on defense, and that’s the problem Rand Paul is running into,” said tariff hater and hawk Jonah Goldberg after Paul’s original 2016 announcement.
Maybe Iraq War supporter Goldberg might agree that being less hawkish would be a positive for Paul in 2028 after what happened in 2026? Especially if opposing protectionism is a priority.
Tariff-loathing neocon Republican turned Democrat Bill Kristol called Paul the “Code Pink wing of the Republican party” back in 2013, comparing the senator to the leftist antiwar group.
Could Paul’s anti-tariff platform bring Kristol back to the GOP in two years time?
I say both in jest. So many neocons backed Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton in 2016 because at the time they considered her the better hawkish choice over “America First” Donald Trump. That same crowd would likely back another Democrat or any other Republican over the more non-interventionist Rand Paul.
Their “tariff” belly-aching is just a ruse.
Cato foreign policy fellow Brandan Buck observed after the midterms:
A note to fellow tariff critics: Yes, it was also the tariffs, but bear in mind that the voices on the establishment right who are blaming the tariffs are not doing so because they oppose the tariffs, but because they support the war. They are deflecting.
— Brandan P. Buck (@brandan_buck) November 10, 2026
Bingo.
Still, to the neocons-who-would-never-vote-for-Rand-Paul-because-they-want-war’s faux point about tariffs, they were a factor and he is really the only Republican senator who has opposed them along with regime change in Tehran.
I reached out to Senator Paul for comment about these issues and the lessons of the elections (disclosure: I am a former staff member for the senator).
“They say victory has a thousand fathers but defeat is an orphan,” Senator Paul told the Libertarian Institute. “Often true, and many are trying to escape the blame for the 2026 elections.”
“What’s true of victory must surely be true of defeat—no one thing is wholly responsible,” he continued. “Some say the Iran war, some say tariffs, some say inflation and gas prices. I say the first two—the war and tariffs—are largely to blame for the resulting inflation and gas prices.”
“So let’s not spend much time arguing which helped cause more of the defeat,” Paul added. “Instead let’s agree they both did, and listen to those of us who were fighting both from day one.”
Should he run, Paul is already leaning into the antiwar GOP mantle and tying it to his fiscal conservatism.
This week he told the Washington Examiner:
I am the only Republican senator in opposition to voting for another $450 billion for the Iran War right now.
At this point, the entire fiscal conservative movement in the Senate is only me.
I don’t say that to brag.
I say that in disappointment.
@petermlaffin @dcexaminer https://t.co/uMPY5EkcSK
— Rand Paul (@RandPaul) November 18, 2026
Disappointment is the right word for the Republican party right now (not just right now, but also, definitely right now).
Perhaps a Republican candidate in 2028 who was on the right side of the war and tariffs could build a winning coalition of actual voters beyond just the small band of neocons now screaming about trade restrictions only because they don’t want to admit everyone hates their war.
Rand Paul hates the war too—and tariffs. Which could make him a Republican unicorn come 2028.


































