Beyond BuzzFeed: The 10 Worst, Most Embarrassing U.S. Media Failures on the Trump/Russia Story

by | Jan 22, 2019

Beyond BuzzFeed: The 10 Worst, Most Embarrassing U.S. Media Failures on the Trump/Russia Story

by | Jan 22, 2019

Buzzfeed was once notorious for traffic-generating “listicles”, but has since become an impressive outlet for deep investigative journalism under editor-in-chief Ben Smith. That outlet was prominently in the news this week thanks to its “bombshell” story about President Trump and Michael Cohen: a story that, like so many others of its kind, blew up in its face, this time when the typically mute Robert Mueller’s office took the extremely rare step to label its key claims “inaccurate.”

But in homage to BuzzFeed’s past viral glory, following are the top ten worst media failures in two-plus-years of Trump/Russia reporting. They are listed in reverse order, as measured by the magnitude of the embarrassment, the hysteria they generated on social media and cable news, the level of journalistic recklessness that produced them, and the amount of damage and danger they caused. This list was extremely difficult to compile in part because news outlets (particularly CNN and MSNBC) often delete from the internet the video segments of their most embarrassing moments. Even more challenging was the fact that the number of worthy nominees is so large that highly meritorious entrees had to be excluded, but are acknowledged at the end with (dis)honorable mention status.

Note that all of these “errors” go only in one direction: namely, exaggerating the grave threat posed by Moscow and the Trump circle’s connection to it. It’s inevitable that media outlets will make mistakes on complex stories. If that’s being done in good faith, one would expect the errors would be roughly 50/50 in terms of the agenda served by the false stories. That is most definitely not the case here. Just as was true in 2002 and 2003, when the media clearly wanted to exaggerate the threat posed by Saddam Hussein and thus all of its “errors” went in that direction, virtually all of its major “errors” in this story are devoted to the same agenda and script:

Read the rest at theintercept.com.

Recent Articles

Recent

Down With Every War!

Down With Every War!

I'd like to say a word about a deceased friend. I don't remember how I met Murray Polner, but we were both academics on Long Island at the time. Our politics were not aligned. But we got along great. We decided to work on a project together: an anthology of the best...

read more
Rand Paul’s 2028 Pitch: Pro-Trade and Anti-War

Rand Paul’s 2028 Pitch: Pro-Trade and Anti-War

Neoconservatives and hawks of various stripes know why Republicans lost disastrously in the 2026 midterm elections: tariffs. They have a point. Polls did show that voter disapproval of President Donald Trump’s tariffs and other issues did help Democrats win big. But...

read more
Bureaucrats On the Road to War

Bureaucrats On the Road to War

The origins of the First World War are often explained through the familiar language of alliances, national interests, and the European balance of power. Yet, as I have previously argued, such explanations mistakenly treat governments as unitary actors, pursuing...

read more

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This