The Trillion Dollar Social Security Trust Fund Robbery

by | Jul 24, 2024

The Trillion Dollar Social Security Trust Fund Robbery

by | Jul 24, 2024

depositphotos 52745925 s 2019

A handout picture obtained from Yemen's Huthi Ansarullah Media Center show a huge column of fire erupting following reported strikes in the Yemeni rebel-held port city of Hodeida

It may be the most successful financial swindle in human history, one more than a dozen times bigger than Bernie Madoff’s $65 billion swindle. By suppressing interest rates using federal Treasury bills, the Federal Reserve Bank has managed to deprive the Social Security OASDI trust fund of more than $900 billion in interest payments since 2001.

And it’s just getting started.

It’s long been a truism among libertarians that because the Social Security program is force-based from taxation, it’s therefore anti-social. In addition, the line goes, there’s no security in it, they’re not worthy of your trust, and there are no funds left.

On the left, the instant response is always a passionate defense of the crown jewel of the New Deal: “This is not true! The trust fund is vested in U.S. Treasury bills, backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. government, earning interest for the Social Security program!” It springs to mind among the oldsters Vice President Al Gore promising how Social Security funds would remain in a “lockbox,” as satirized back in the year 2000 by “Saturday Night Live.”

There was for a long time at least a hint of truth to this defense of the New Deal. The Social Security Administration brags in its press releases that “A market rate of interest is paid to the trust funds on the bonds they hold, and when those bonds reach maturity or are needed to pay benefits, the Treasury redeems them.” And indeed, the federal government does keep a ledger of how much interest this trust fund earns in Treasury bills.

In 2022, the Social Security Administration recorded the Social Security trust fund as possessing a $2.829 trillion surplus in its OASDI trust fund (the main Social Security trust fund), earning more than $66 billion in interest on those trust fund reserves. That $66 billion amounted to a 2.8% interest rate.

That sounds good.

But after an 8.0% Consumer Price Index increase that year, the real interest rate in 2022 after inflation was negative, -5.2%, representing a $147.1 billion loss in real dollar terms that year alone.

In 2001, the Federal Reserve Bank began its deliberate policy of suppressing interest rates to historic lows, sending real yields on Treasury bills into the basement, cutting in half the real (after adjusting for CPI inflation) interest gains accumulated by the trust funds. Real interest yields for the trust funds fell from an average of 2.8% annually 1962-2000 to just 1.4% since 2001 in the now Fed-suppressed market, thereby taking more than $900 billion in value from the Social Security trust fund since 2001 without anyone even noticing.

And it’s only getting worse. 2024 is shaping up to be the fourth straight year of negative real interest for the Social Security trust fund, with no end in sight. You read that right; the Social Security trust fund has lost value every one of the last four years because of low interest rates artificially engineered by the Federal Reserve Bank.

social security tf interest over years

Ironically, even though the Social Security trust fund is officially losing nearly $50 billion annually (in an amount that’s increasing every year) the annual lost value in the form of lost compound interest would have more than matched losses for 2023 and 2024.

Social Security program’s pay-go system, where current workers pay the benefits for those who retire, is not sustainable in the long-run in an era when the birth rates plummet and people are living longer in retirement. More longevity and going from a baby boom to baby bust explains why Social Security payroll taxes have already increased from the 2.0% in 1935 to some 12.4% today, not counting Medicare payroll taxes. According to the Congressional Research Service on May 23, 2024, “By 2098, the cost of the program is projected to exceed income by an amount equal to 4.64% of taxable payroll (costs are projected to exceed income by about 25%).” That means working people’s payroll taxes are going to go up to pay out the same benefits, assuming they don’t cut benefits by postponing the full retirement age further than they already have.

Interest losses to the trust funds are likely not only to continue, but accelerate as a result of Federal Reserve policies that are expected to continue to suppress interest rates after unleashing inflation with money-printing. The way the Social Security Administration calculates interest received by the Social Security trust fund is to take an average of all U.S. Treasury bills (i.e., T-bills) that mature four years or further in the future. It means that even if the Federal Reserve Bank raises interest rates right now, something they’re unlikely to do, interest earned by the trust fund will remain historically low because the law continues to include T-bills issued twenty and twenty-five years ago into its interest calculation for the trust funds. According to the Social Security Administration:

The formula sets the rate applicable in a given month to the average market yield on marketable interest-bearing securities of the Federal government which are not due or callable until after 4 years from the last business day of the prior month (the day when the rate is determined). The average yield must then be rounded to the nearest eighth of 1 percent.”

The knock against privatizing Social Security and investing the trust funds in the stock market has always been that investing the stock market was too “risky” and investing the funds in Treasury bills insured against losses. And it’s true that, while yields for the stock market have been consistently higher in the long-term, stocks have shown higher volatility in their gains.

social security tf v. sandp 3 year rollling average

It’s clear, however, that investment in Treasury bills doesn’t insure against significant losses over multiple years, especially during times of higher price inflation. The Federal Reserve Bank’s policies of inflation and suppressing interest rates, and thus yields on government debt, means that losses to the Social Security trust fund will continue for years to come and number in the trillions compared to a free market rate of federal debt. And it will be much more in comparison with stocks or other investments.

Libertarians will probably see a dark irony in that the crown jewel of the progressive movement of 110 years ago bankrupting the crown jewel of the New Deal from ninety years ago.

And the left would probably be mad at the Fed’s naked class warfare against working people…if only they could do math.

Thomas Eddlem

Thomas Eddlem

Thomas R. Eddlem is the William Norman Grigg Fellow at the Libertarian Institute, an economist and a freelance writer published by more than 20 periodicals and websites, including the Ron Paul Institute, the Future of Freedom Foundation, the Foundation for Economic Education, The New American, LewRockwell.com, and—of course—right here at the Libertarian Institute. He has written three books, A Rogue's Sedition: Essays Against Omnipotent Government, and two books of academic resources for high school teachers of history, Primary Source American History and The World Speaks: World History Since 1750 Using Primary Source Documents. Tom holds a masters of applied economics and data scientist certification from Boston College (2021) and is the treasurer of the Massachusetts Libertarian Party. He lives in Taunton, Massachusetts with his wife Cathy and family.

View all posts

Our Books

Shop books published by the Libertarian Institute.

libetarian institute longsleeve shirt

Support via Amazon Smile

Our Books

libertarian inst books

Recent Articles

Recent

Syrian Civil War Redux

Syrian Civil War Redux

You turn your head for one moment to focus on turkey and stuffing, and all of the sudden the Syrian Civil War restarts. The conflict which erupted during the 2011 Arab Spring, and which over the course of a decade killed over half a million people, has been static...

read more
Secrecy and the Divine Right to Deceive

Secrecy and the Divine Right to Deceive

Secrecy and lying are two sides of the same political coin. The Supreme Court declared in 1936, “An informed public is the most potent of all restraints upon misgovernment.” Thus, conniving politicians have no choice but to drop an Iron Curtain around Washington....

read more
Donald Trump’s Economic Wars Serve No Purpose

Donald Trump’s Economic Wars Serve No Purpose

The incoming Donald Trump administration seems determined to wage as many economic wars as it can. The president-elect reportedly plans to pursue another “maximum pressure” campaign against Iran with the goal of “bankrupting” the country. Now he is threatening new...

read more

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This