Time to Rethink North Korean Sanctions

by | Jun 22, 2017

Time to Rethink North Korean Sanctions

by | Jun 22, 2017

Earlier this year, TV stations all over South Korea were ablaze with scenes of Pyongyang’s latest missile tests. It’s now clear that North Korea remains firmly resolute on pursuing a dangerous mission, even after nearly ten years of suffering the world’s disapproval on tests like this and on its human rights record. Yet, sanctions continue. The Obama Administration has issued newer, tougher sanctions, some of which have been approved by the U.N. Security Council.

Supporters of sanctions hold onto the conviction that there’s a “tipping point” for the North Korean government. When that tipping point is reached, they’ll be forced to negotiate with the U.N.

Nonetheless, there is no evidence which even hints North Korea will ever fold along these lines. The U.N. sanctions are a response to an entire decade of ongoing nuclear tests, starting in 2006. Both financial and humanitarian aid have been severely reduced but so far a satisfactory response has eluded those who imposed these sanctions.

Like an incorrigible juvenile delinquent, North Korea persists in barreling down a dangerous road, undeterred by threats, warnings, and small punishments. Knowing the track record of North Korea, those imposing the sanctions are creating little more than political bravado and provocation, when what we really need is skilled diplomacy.

But there’s a new danger with these latest sanctions: they effectively blacklist Kim Jong-un personally, freezing his assets along with those of his top officials. This is dangerous provocation, since from what we’ve seen so far in North Korea, all evidence points towards a stubborn, unwavering leadership who’s quick to respond militarily rather than diplomatically.

For example, with almost glee, North Korea announced at the beginning of this year that they’d conducted a hydrogen bomb test. There’s doubt it ever happened, but nevertheless, tougher sanctions soon followed. And what did North Korea do? I refer you back to the beginning of this article: two short-range ballistic missiles were fired into the East Sea… in defiant, teenager-like rebellion against UN Security Council resolutions imposed earlier.

In this context, it’s easy to argue that sanctions are doing more harm than good, actually pushing North Korea closer to actual military aggression rather than enticing them towards the round table of discussion. Indeed, the result is now even more grim than we’d hoped: last month, the United States and South Korea announced their decision to deploy an advanced missile system called THAAD (Terminal High Altitude Area Defense), in direct response to North Korea’s missile and nuclear threats.

Sanctions against North Korea have not only failed to produce the intended results of slowing down their nuclear weapons program or convincing them to improve human rights in that country. They’re actually hindering humanitarian efforts.

Read the rest at Students for Liberty.

Recent Articles

Recent

Down With Every War!

Down With Every War!

I'd like to say a word about a deceased friend. I don't remember how I met Murray Polner, but we were both academics on Long Island at the time. Our politics were not aligned. But we got along great. We decided to work on a project together: an anthology of the best...

read more
Rand Paul’s 2028 Pitch: Pro-Trade and Anti-War

Rand Paul’s 2028 Pitch: Pro-Trade and Anti-War

Neoconservatives and hawks of various stripes know why Republicans lost disastrously in the 2026 midterm elections: tariffs. They have a point. Polls did show that voter disapproval of President Donald Trump’s tariffs and other issues did help Democrats win big. But...

read more
Bureaucrats On the Road to War

Bureaucrats On the Road to War

The origins of the First World War are often explained through the familiar language of alliances, national interests, and the European balance of power. Yet, as I have previously argued, such explanations mistakenly treat governments as unitary actors, pursuing...

read more

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This