Royal Navy Carrier Deployment: Failure is in the Cards

by | Apr 11, 2025

Royal Navy Carrier Deployment: Failure is in the Cards

by | Apr 11, 2025

pwcarrier1

HMS Prince of Wales will lead Carrier Strike Group 25 on a deployment to the Pacific.

The Prince of Wales has suffered many propulsion issues (it’s a non-nuclear carrier) and engineering casualties.

Non-nuclear carrier operations in war in the 21st century rely on static port refueling or underway POL replenishment. In peacetime, just dandy. In wartime in the missile age we live in, a disaster in the making. No port will be safe and no “blue water anchorage” for logistical refit will be safe. My forecast: the HMS Prince of Wales will not complete this task.

They will suffer an existential engineering casualty.This is a huge risk because towing it back to the UK will be no mean task if they don’t choose to do repairs in the Pacific, possibly in Australia.

If it makes the deployment and returns to the UK with no issues, I will gladly admit being wrong.

The Queen Elizabeth-class aircraft carriers, specifically HMS Queen Elizabeth and HMS Prince of Wales, are the largest warships ever built for the Royal Navy.

Here are some of the main problems:

Cost overruns: The project was initially estimated to cost around $4 billion, but the final cost was around $8 billion. This is a significant increase, and the project has been criticized for poor cost management.

Delays: The carriers were initially scheduled to be commissioned in 2016 and 2018, respectively. However, they were delayed several times, with HMS Queen Elizabeth being commissioned in 2017 and HMS Prince of Wales being commissioned in 2019.

Technical issues: The carriers have experienced several technical issues, including problems with the propulsion system, electrical systems, and communication systems. These issues have led to delays and cancellations of sea trials. Lack of operational capability: The carriers are not yet fully operational, and it is expected to take several years to achieve full operational capability. This is due to a range of factors, including the need for additional training and the development of new procedures.

Limited air defense capabilities: The carriers do not have a dedicated air defense system, which is a concern for some analysts. This means that the ships rely on other vessels or air defense systems to provide protection against aerial threats. Necessarily, this plagues all modern carriers in the missile age.

2022 engineering casualty on the carrier:

https://t.co/vnGb6L6MDX

Bill Buppert

Bill Buppert

Bill Buppert is the host of Chasing Ghosts: An Irregular Warfare Podcast and a contributor over time to various liberty endeavors. He served in the military for nearly a quarter century and contractor tours after retirement on occasion and was a combat tourist in a number of neo-imperialist shit-pits around the world.

He can be found on twitter at @wbuppert and reached via email at cgpodcast@pm.me.

View all posts

Our Books

Shop books published by the Libertarian Institute.

libetarian institute longsleeve shirt

Our Books

cb0cb1ef 3fcb 417d 80d8 4eef7bbd8290

Recent Articles

Recent

“The Bisexuals of Politics”

“The Bisexuals of Politics”

In a recent debate on the Joe Rogan Experience, between Douglas Murray and Dave Smith, Murray accused libertarians as being the “bisexuals of politics.” An interesting claim, one that assumes politics is in itself is a binary. Or that those in the ‘liberty’ spectrum,...

read more

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This